git alias: Commit with arguments & push in a single command

I try to convince my coworkers to leave svn and switch to git. One problem I see coming is: It’s complicated and error-prone to have to do git commit and git push separately. So I was thinking about a git ci alias, which commits the changes and pushes it right to the server. I know, how to do that, but:

The problem is, that I want to give arguments like -m “” to git commit. So

  • could not open git/commit_editmsg
  • Install specific git commit with pip
  • git filter-branch --msg-filter to reword a pushed commit message
  • Amend comment message from older commits using SHA ID
  • When creating a new git repository with 40,000 things, so I have to uncomment each in the COMMIT file?
  • Recover unreferenced commits from remote git repository
  • git ci -m "Cool change"
    

    should execute

    git commit -m "Cool change" && git push
    

    How can I do so?

  • git workflow with multiple, different remotes
  • What exactly does the ReCommit feature in TortoiseGit do?
  • How to determine is there a rebase in git-hook?
  • How to commit/push a Git tag with Gradle?
  • What minimal files needed for Microblaze rebuild
  • Syntax error when adding SSH key in GitLab CI
  • 2 Solutions collect form web for “git alias: Commit with arguments & push in a single command”

    you can “hide” git much like the “git achievement” project does. This will enable you to add scripts that look like git commands. Your basic flow should be:

    git pull --rebase
    

    so that history is linear like what they are used to in SVN’s update. But you must tell them that they may need to get rid of conflicts and tell them about or alias git add -A && git rebase --continue. I suggest turning on rerere and sharing those resolutions across the team with a script attached to the “alias” you’re going to make for this.

    Next, hide commit with something like this:

    git add -A
    git commit -m "message"
    git pull --rebase
    git push origin <current branch> # or set up tracking and omit the last 2 args
    

    These should fail gracefully on conflicts as well.

    here is the link to git achievements:

    http://benjamin-meyer.blogspot.com/2010/03/git-achievements.html

    Although I think this is not helping them in the long run, I hope this helps for now.

    For the general problem of adding arguments to one of multiple commands as an alias, the git alias works almost exactly like a normal *nix alias. The only difference it that unless the git alias starts with ! it’s assumed that git should be prepended to the command. Any arguments used in combination with an alias is prepended, to insert an argument into a loger string of commands you need some kind of shell command for parsing the arguments. See for instance this question for arguments.

    But for this question in particular. I agree with the others that this is a useful thing to do. If you’re going to push immediately after committing, I assume each user have their own public private repo (readonly for others) so that the push will “never” fail, which means it works very different from svn anyway; they must pull from different repos etc.

    If you’re instead are using one public “master repo” that everyone pulls and pushes to, this would be a even worse idea, since when the push inevitably will fail sometime, they are trained not to use “commit” then “push” but use your “ci” alias to commit and push changes; When they try to “re-commit” the changes the second part will not run because the first command does not finish with success status (but prints no changes added to commit (use "git add" and/or "git commit -a") instead).

    Git Baby is a git and github fan, let's start git clone.